Last week I had the opportunity to talk about Blue Ocean Strategy at the 2010 iDate conference; the largest conference for the online dating world.
Click here to view the presentation.
Early analysis revealed the field is mired in the red ocean of competition and technical innovation. Given how little the industry has changed I expected maybe three people might be interested in applying Blue Ocean Strategy for their websites. I couldn't have been proven more wrong.
The room was packed and the audience completely engaged. This was especially surprising given that it was a morning presentation and the conference was in Miami's South Beach District, not exactly a venue to inspire people to wake up early for discussions about business strategy in dark rooms. Figuring out how to lift oneself out of the daily dreariness of red ocean competition trumps the siren song of the very real blue ocean outside.
Because of time constraints we didn't have time to review all the components of Blue Ocean Strategy so focused on value innovation, and even then tried to dig into the often misunderstood concepts of non-buyers, buyer value, and the six path framework.
One great example of buyer value came from the popular dating website Plenty of Fish. The enormously popular websites online chat system went down months ago. All their users noticed but none apparently cared. Their metrics don't appear to have been affected, users quickly found alternative methods of communication; it was clear that users of the site found little if any value in the on-site chat system despite that maintaining it presumably required both capital and time that could have been better spent on factors that added real utility.
Along the same lines we tried to focus on a perennially misunderstood concept: key factors that should be reduced or eliminated. It's not uncommon to see companies try to re-characterize these by defining them in the inverse. For example somebody may write "Reduce user frustration" ... presumably by adding lots of features a project champion wants. This couldn't be more wrong: factors we eliminate or reduce are factors buyers and non-buyers find valuable but where the value does not align with the cost. In the example above we're actually raising ease of use. When we phrase the key factor like that we're forced to examine the importance of Ease of Use to buyers and non-buyers, and -- almost more importantly -- we need to find other factors to eliminate and reduce to pay for our increased ease of use. Remember that it is substantially harder to eliminate and reduce factors than it is to raise and create them.
My hope is that over the next months or years somebody comes along with a better way of matching people online, and maybe even retains those previously first-tier non-buyers, helping them build a foundation for their budding relationships. If all works out well we'll see offerings that focus on the larger interests affecting singles, looping in the second-tier non-buyers. Finally, we may even learn something from the third tier non-buyers -- parents in happy relationships looking for playgroups for their kids, couples looking for other couples to hang out with, job hunters looking for work opportunities -- that can be applied to transform the red ocean of the online dating industry into the blue ocean outside our conference center.
One thing I learned about myself is that talking about Blue Ocean Strategy is fun! I've been working with the framework for ten years now. I'm not sure I'd want to stray far from the tech or web industries but if people want to learn more about BOS, or apply it within their own businesses, please don't hesitate to contact me at olenick @ valueinnovation.net.
Popular Posts
Saturday, January 30, 2010
What is Value? Blue Ocean Strategy & Online Dating; iDate 2010 Conference Presentation
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
2:36 PM
2
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, dating industry, make competition irrelevant, presentation, red oceans, technical innovation, value, web business
Thursday, April 24, 2008
We study non-customers, not try to create them...
I've published quotes I thought were brilliant so here's one that's the opposite, from TechCrunch:
"I had a chance to play around with the SearchMonkey application creation tool, which is actually quite straightforward (if you’re comfortable with PHP, XSLT, and DataRSS)." (emphasis mine)A small part of me says the author must be expressing sarcasm, but the realist in me says he wrote that with a straight face. When quotes like this start pouring out of Silicon Valley it's a strong indicator of an impending correction.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
1:42 PM
0
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, hot air, sarcasm, technical innovation
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
Blue Ocean Strategy: Microsoft & Yahoo -- Build a better search
Writing again about MS and Yahoo. Yahoo came in with essentially flat earnings. Depending upon how one parses the numbers Google's profitability grew 30-40 percent during the same quarter. Google is clearly a Blue Ocean Strategy company (click here for a BOS analysis of Google: "Bloogle: Making Portals Irrelevant"). Based on earnings MS CEO Steve Ballmer says he's ready to walk away from the deal. He's probably just bluffing but walking away would be the best move.
It isn't that MS doesn't need the reach of a world-class search engine: it's just that Yahoo doesn't fit that model. There are some great Yahoo properties -- Flickr, Groups, Messenger -- but the centerpiece of Yahoo is search and Yahoo's search stinks. The problem with Yahoo search is that it's adulterated. Yahoo liberally co-mingles paid search results with organic results: doing so violates the integrity and credibility of the results. Many consumers outright understand this; others just sense that something is "wrong" or "weird" with the results (I've heard both words used).
Yahoo searchers feel like they've walked onto a used-car lot: they put their guard up and many don't return. Yahoo used to have a strategic advantage by human-indexed search results but that fell apart when they switched to paid inclusion; pay Yahoo a few hundred dollars and you'll become relevant, even if you're a third-rate hack in your field.
For those not in the know paid inclusion is like paying for a job interview: the job you stand to receive is junk. Similarly, Yahoo's search results are worthless. Since virtually everybody knows this at some level only the most clueless are left searching on Yahoo, which dilutes the value of the search results to advertisers. These diluted results -- stemming from a lack of credibility -- push Yahoo to do more to monetize results, which typically means more dumb tricks like co-mingled results, which even further dilutes credibility. The resulting death spiral they're in is well documented and will be studied in business and journalism text books for many years.
Microsoft: if you want to build a better search then build a better search. Look at the tiers of non-customers and apply each through the six path framework to find the key factors of a great search engine. Google's clobbered you and Yahoo but you two set them up perfectly: you, Microsoft, focused too much on technology innovation and Yahoo self-destructed. The only way to fight a BOS offering is with another BOS offering. Google redefined the rules once; you can and should do the same back to them.
Without going into a full-scale analysis I'd think the key factors of a Google beating search engine would include Price, Ease of use, Scope of items returned (not just websites), Credibility of results, Comprehensiveness, Relevance of search results, Honesty and integrity of search provider, Objective and subjective descriptions of results, and Reward to business owners for playing fairly. There's probably a few more, and some of these probably need refinement. But buried in there, I'll bet, is the recipe for a genuine Google killer. It won't be cheap to build, but it'll cost a lot less than buying Yahoo and trying to reform its culture, brand, and technology.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
9:48 AM
0
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, honesty, microsoft, mistake, search, technical innovation, web business, yahoo
Wednesday, April 16, 2008
Blue Ocean Strategy & Technology Innovation
I can't count the number of times I've heard marketers rant on to say that technology has nothing to do with innovation and that Blue Ocean Strategy somehow supports this notion.
Summarizing: Blue Ocean Strategy puts customer value at the center of any new offering. Customer value is never defined in terms of raw technology, but the technology is catalytic to the value: the value will never get realized without the technology.
Let's examine some examples:
- The Wii wouldn't be without its small, inexpensive accelerometer driving the Wii remote. The accelerometer allows the creation of the magic wand: no accelerometer = no magic wand. However, Nintendo is not marketing accelerometers.
- Google reads a users mind to return relevant search results. However, these results are driven by a brilliant search algorithm and massive data centers. No brilliant algorithm and no enormous infrastructure = no mind reading web search. However, the end users never see the technology.
- The Toyota Prius is an engineering masterpiece. A user drives around with more computing power than the entire world had not long ago powered by computer-designed technology no human with a slide-rule could ever have mastered. No computers to design and run the Prius = no magic high mileage car. However, end users never see the technology.
- Even the Blue Ocean Strategy case studies in the book all have technology driving them. Starbuck's uses extremely sophisticated GIS systems and water filtration technology, Cirque du Soleil low noise, portable power generation and stage technology, the NYPD well documented crime tracking software; the list is endles...
I'll give marketers who say the technology doesn't matter the benefit of the doubt that they're not just trying to cover-up their own unwillingness or inability to learn about the technology driving their industry. However, when these people pipe-up and start shouting that "technology doesn't matter" tell them that they're absolutely wrong. It's just that technical innovation must be defined in terms that drive utility to the end user, but that doesn't mean the technology is unimportant.
Quoting the book "[acting] on the assumption that bleeding-edge technology is equivalent to bleeding-edge utility for buyers ... is rarely the case." Blue Ocean Strategy, pg. 120. That doesn't mean technology doesn't matter; it means the technology must always be described for it's utility and value to the buyer.
There would be no Nintendo Wii, Google, or Toyota Prius without extremely sophisticated new technology. The NYPD would be chasing down muggers aimlessly, Cirque du Soleil wouldn't be the same without the dramatic lighting, and Starbucks wouldn't magically be located in great locations. Just because the end-user never sees, understands, or appreciates the technology doesn't mean the business/product developer doesn't need to.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
9:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, catalytic technology, google, innovation, prius, starbucks, technical innovation, technology, toyota, wii
Monday, April 14, 2008
Blue Ocean Strategy: Non-Customers
One of the primary components of a successful six-path study is the focus on customers and non-customers. Non-customers, which are divided into three tiers, each of which has a specific definition, are especially important.
Paraphrasing from the book, the first tier of non-customers are current customers who are getting ready to leave. The second tier are people who consciously decide against your product. The third tier are people in distant markets.
Let's bring that back to earth using the the Nintendo Wii and -- more importantly -- it's predecessor, the Nintendo Game Cube. Young boys loved the Game Cube: it was small and cute and cheap; it even had a handle so they could pick it up and carry it to play with friends. The problem is that the core group of boys who played the Game Cube would "graduate" to a Sony PS2 or Microsoft XBox. These boys were the first tier of non-customers: current customers who were likely to leave. The second tier of non-customers were girls: they were the same age, had access to the same resources, but just didn't show interest in the Game Cube. Finally, geriatrics in nursing homes were the third tier: they thought a Game Cube was the box containing the checkers board.
Nintendo of course turned those tiers of non-customers entirely on their head. By studying the six-paths and applying what they learned to redefine the market boundaries they built the Wii and the Nintendo DS to appeal to both customers and non-customers alike. Boys love the Wii, but so do girls, young men, mom's, and just about everybody who tries it. Changing the key factors to attract girls to play the DS was especially inexpensive albeit brilliant: they came out with a version in pink. As for the Wii, it was renamed from it's code-name the Nintendo Revolution. Boys loved the name "Revolution" -- my son still does -- but they could live with the Wii. Girls went for the Wii, they had no interest in their brothers revolution.
One company that has a massive swarm of first tier non-customers is Microsoft. Vista is a disaster. One commentator, writing about the merits of Vista, described a key benefit as the inclusion of Snipping Tool, an application that takes screen-shots. That is, the strongest proponents of a multi-billion dollar project that took years to complete, greatly increased the hardware requirements needed to run, and cost almost double its predecessor were reduced to citing the inclusion of a trivial piece of freeware.
People are getting ready to flee Vista. I personally have a Vista "Ultimate" computer, a Macintosh, and I just ordered an Ubuntu (Linux) machine from Dell. Long term, putting up with the sluggish speed and instability of Windows just doesn't make sense, especially given that I'm sure Microsoft will soon enough want even more than the $400 I already paid for this awful operating system. In the case of Vista, it's not that the advantages outweigh the disadvantages: there are no advantages I can think of except that I need to use this computer to test software because Windows is what most of my clients use. If my clients change, so will I. I'll probably change anyway, and keep a Windows computer only for testing.
I'm a vocal and classic first-tier non-customer for Windows. Microsoft has literally millions more like me. I'm not being alarmist or anti-Microsoft: Gartner calls the current state of Windows "untenable" and has announced that Windows is "collapsing." Microsoft engaged in classic technical innovation: innovation for the sake of innovation, when releasing this awful beast. Now they're driving away their customers in droves.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
9:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, buyers non-buyers, game consoles, game cube, linux, nintendo ds, non-customers, technical innovation, vista, wii, xbox
Tuesday, February 19, 2008
NPI: Making sure good ideas die an early death
NPI is the six-sigma term for New Product Introductions. Most companies that refer to the metric use it as the end measure of an oftentimes elaborate process to create new products. The measure is usually an integer representing the raw number of new products pushed into the market, entirely without regard to quality or consumer value.
NPI epitomizes red ocean thinking. The measure itself entirely fails to measure the quality of the "new" product, or the value to the consumer. If a red ocean marketer can get their "NPI point" by renaming the ADXL330 accelerometer the ADXL331 accelerometer they'll do just that. A Blue Ocean Innovator, on the other hand, will bundle the thing into a handheld gaming controller and sell it as a key element -- a magic wand -- in the Wii.
NPI's and six-sigma are all about the containment of risk. The processes serve partly as the antibodies of an organization, making sure that all new cells "fit" and attacking any that don't. The problem, of course, is that Blue Ideas usually don't fit at first. Blue Ocean Strategy requires you to redefine your market boundaries. Doing that, by definition, often results in products and services -- businesses -- that the rest of the organization will see as disruptive and dangerous.
The irony, of course, is that remaining with the status quo -- being stuck in a Red Ocean of product line extensions, price cutting, and the never-ending battle with suppliers, customers, etc.. -- is the real danger to the business. Much like an auto-immune disease kills its host by tricking an organisms defensive mechanisms into the mistaken belief that "good" cells are harmful, so to do "bad" business processes (and people) make a company believe necessary change is dangerous, disruptive, or reckless.
This is one business problem I don't have a suggested cure for other than to watch your people and processes, and make sure the conservative Red's aren't over-running the Blue's. B-school professors and corporate managers disagree about the extent that these people should be separated. Some believe large companies are hopeless: that they'll never adequately encourage innovation. Others believe a combination of the right policies, processes, and incentives will allow innovation to thrive.
Whatever your belief -- whether a giant company really can push out organic innovation -- (hello, Apple) or whether it's hopeless (hiya, Microsoft) -- it's important to be cognizant of the challenges and to constantly adjust your policies.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
3:33 PM
0
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, market boundaries, npi, six sigma, technical innovation, wii
