Last week I had the opportunity to talk about Blue Ocean Strategy at the 2010 iDate conference; the largest conference for the online dating world.
Click here to view the presentation.
Early analysis revealed the field is mired in the red ocean of competition and technical innovation. Given how little the industry has changed I expected maybe three people might be interested in applying Blue Ocean Strategy for their websites. I couldn't have been proven more wrong.
The room was packed and the audience completely engaged. This was especially surprising given that it was a morning presentation and the conference was in Miami's South Beach District, not exactly a venue to inspire people to wake up early for discussions about business strategy in dark rooms. Figuring out how to lift oneself out of the daily dreariness of red ocean competition trumps the siren song of the very real blue ocean outside.
Because of time constraints we didn't have time to review all the components of Blue Ocean Strategy so focused on value innovation, and even then tried to dig into the often misunderstood concepts of non-buyers, buyer value, and the six path framework.
One great example of buyer value came from the popular dating website Plenty of Fish. The enormously popular websites online chat system went down months ago. All their users noticed but none apparently cared. Their metrics don't appear to have been affected, users quickly found alternative methods of communication; it was clear that users of the site found little if any value in the on-site chat system despite that maintaining it presumably required both capital and time that could have been better spent on factors that added real utility.
Along the same lines we tried to focus on a perennially misunderstood concept: key factors that should be reduced or eliminated. It's not uncommon to see companies try to re-characterize these by defining them in the inverse. For example somebody may write "Reduce user frustration" ... presumably by adding lots of features a project champion wants. This couldn't be more wrong: factors we eliminate or reduce are factors buyers and non-buyers find valuable but where the value does not align with the cost. In the example above we're actually raising ease of use. When we phrase the key factor like that we're forced to examine the importance of Ease of Use to buyers and non-buyers, and -- almost more importantly -- we need to find other factors to eliminate and reduce to pay for our increased ease of use. Remember that it is substantially harder to eliminate and reduce factors than it is to raise and create them.
My hope is that over the next months or years somebody comes along with a better way of matching people online, and maybe even retains those previously first-tier non-buyers, helping them build a foundation for their budding relationships. If all works out well we'll see offerings that focus on the larger interests affecting singles, looping in the second-tier non-buyers. Finally, we may even learn something from the third tier non-buyers -- parents in happy relationships looking for playgroups for their kids, couples looking for other couples to hang out with, job hunters looking for work opportunities -- that can be applied to transform the red ocean of the online dating industry into the blue ocean outside our conference center.
One thing I learned about myself is that talking about Blue Ocean Strategy is fun! I've been working with the framework for ten years now. I'm not sure I'd want to stray far from the tech or web industries but if people want to learn more about BOS, or apply it within their own businesses, please don't hesitate to contact me at olenick @ valueinnovation.net.
Popular Posts
Saturday, January 30, 2010
What is Value? Blue Ocean Strategy & Online Dating; iDate 2010 Conference Presentation
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
2:36 PM
2
comments
Labels: blue ocean strategy, dating industry, make competition irrelevant, presentation, red oceans, technical innovation, value, web business
Thursday, May 8, 2008
Newton & Product development
Like many engineers that cross over to the business world I find it amazing how the Rules of Physics applies to business. The most obviously applicable to creating new businesses and products are Newton's Three Laws of Motion. Let's examine them:
1. Objects at rest tend to stay at rest. How many times have we seen a company that's making no apparent movement towards innovation say that they'll magically start? Windows Live manager Brian Hall told an investor conference this week "...[Microsoft is] now are focused on how we grow as fast as possible organically." Huh? The web browser was invented fifteen years ago but Microsoft is going to start magically growing organically. This just isn't the way things work, which leads us to Newton's Second Law:
2. The velocity of acceleration is mass times force. That is, the bigger something is, the more force is required to make it move. It's common for companies to underestimate the effort required to "change the needle" -- to launch a new business or product. I've often compared new business development to a three-stage rocket launch. The first stage uses almost all the fuel, is massively risky, and has the highest chance of catastrophic failure. Luckily the whole thing is over in a few minutes. The second stage uses exponentially less fuel, is much less risky, and really just positions the spacecraft for orbit. It lasts longer than the first stage, but typically lasts no more than a few hours. The third stage is orbit: just going around and around. Most companies live in Stage 3; they don't have the risk tolerance or the people to pull off a Stage 1 launch even if they want to, and most secretly don't. People mustn't underestimate the amount of energy required to launch a substantial business. Once we've launched our business we get to Newton's Third Law, which we should have anticipated while planning:
3. For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. I obviously believe much more in Blue Ocean Strategy -- making competitor's irrelevant -- than Porter's Five Forces, duking it out. But companies should never underestimate the reaction of competitors to a new initiative. Competitors don't like to become irrelevant, and most will do everything they can to prevent it.
Posted by
Michael Olenick
at
10:22 AM
0
comments
Labels: analysis, blue ocean strategy, growth, make competition irrelevant, newton, philosophy, strategic framework
