Showing posts with label six path framework. Show all posts
Showing posts with label six path framework. Show all posts

Saturday, April 5, 2008

Blue Ocean Strategy: Seeing through the clutter

As the original Clinton campaign would have put it, "it's the six-path framework, stupid." Seriously ... a lot of people ask how to actually use Blue Ocean Strategy to make a new business. I've written a longer post that goes into each specific step, but realized that I skipped an executive summary that may be even more important.

Summarizing the 240 page academic book into one sentence: use the six-path framework to find the key factors of a business through the lens of customers and non-customers, then use the four actions framework to redefine the market boundaries of that business while adhering to tipping-point leadership and fair process to increase the chances your organization will be able to execute your new business. OK ... it was a run-on sentence, and it greatly oversimplifies. Still, it's a start.

As a product/business developer I'll take things a step farther. Listen to the Harry Chapin song "Six String Orchestra" where a young man dreams of being a great singer. In reality, he can't play his instrument and receives nothing but negative feedback from everybody around him. But in his mind, he hears the beautiful songs of the future, knowing that he'll have to do the hard work, practice a lot, and find the right people to make music with.

Product and business development is like that. I once had an early version of a product that went on to do great generously described as a "mud hut" by a seasoned software developer. He wasn't being negative: just saying that he understood my vision but that a lot of work is needed to turn that vision into reality.

Some people will disparage or sabotage your ideas out of petty jealousy, or because they fear their livelihood or relevance will be threatened either by the business you create, or the fact you (and not they) created it. But I've found many aren't acting in bad faith: they just don't understand where you're going and don't have the brainpower to see the end of the path.

Blue Ocean Strategy helps you not only figure out where that path should lead to, but gives us a series of powerful tools that help communicate that to others. Blue Ocean Strategy provides a roadmap, but isn't magic: you, the product and business developer have to figure out where that road is leading to and push your organization down that path.

The six-path framework is how you, the person trying to redefine a business or industry, find those key factors that are vital to the success of your business: it's the music you hear in your head, that you know you're capable of.

In the search for key factors, it's not uncommon to quickly jot down a list of factors: don't do this. Remember the old software engineering term GIGO: Garbage In, Garbage Out. The process of identifying and isolating key factors should be long and painstaking: there's nothing easy about it. You should really be uncomfortable with the key factors you eliminate and reduce. Making things worse, the longer you've been in the industry the more difficult the process will be, because you'll be steeped in the standard boundaries by which companies are already competing.

But if you use the six-path framework to find those key factors, then apply the four actions framework against them, you'll find that music you knew was there will come alive in real life. You'll invent a Wii, create the Prius, or launch the next Google. But never underestimate the amount of raw effort that went into each of these individual efforts, or that must go into yours if it has a chance of succeeding.

Saturday, February 23, 2008

Blue Ocean Strategy In Real Life

IRL = In Real Life. Answering a question I've been asked a few times: Yes, I've used Blue Ocean Strategy to create products. Some went on to do great; others not so great. Whatever the eventual outcome, I believe in the process and wouldn't spawn a new business without going through it.

Here are the steps, in order, I personally recommend to create a BOS business. Remember, everybody seems to have a different answer to this question. Like everything else here, this is solely my personal opinion.


  1. Create a Pioneer-Migrator-Settler Chart. Be honest: many companies are big red blobs that may not shrink in total revenue, but will shrink dramatically in gross profit, over time.

  2. Do a comprehensive six-path study in this order:
    1) time/trends, 2) chain of buyers, 3) strategic groups, 4) alternative industries, 5) complementary products & services, then 6) functional/emotional appeal. Why that order? I'll explain in a later post. Officially, the order doesn't matter, but I came up with this after a lot of thought and having been through the process a few times. It's important to study these for both current buyers and, more importantly, non-customers.

  3. In parallel, send some engineers to figure out possible things that can be used in the "Create" portion of the Four Actions Framework, coming up later. I've developed these rules for a successful Create element: 1) there's an overwhelming chance the element will involve technology, 2) the technology will be catalytic: the end-user won't notice it directly, 3) the technology must exist and is usually mature, 4) you're looking for a new use of the technology, and 5) the technology is usually, though not always, from a different industry. They should be spending more time at Disneyworld and CES, and less in the lab. You might need to attach a marketer to them to keep them focused. If you do, find a creative geek (shameless plug: or just hire me to work with your engineers).

  4. Abstract key elements from the above and plot your As-Is Value Curve: allow no more than 10 key elements; the fewer the better. Don't allow participants to guess in advance which should be eliminated, reduced, raised, and created (ERRC'd).

  5. Complete your Strategy Canvas by plotting substitute offerings.

  6. Figure out which key elements to eliminate and reduce. Eliminate and reduce substantive key elements: if there aren't a few people who swear you'll ruin the company by eliminating and reducing these -- and who show how important the elements are by pointing out how much competitors are working on these -- the elements aren't important enough.

  7. Given what's left, raise it -- high. This is fun: it's the easiest part of the process. Make sure you don't slip into technical innovation, innovation for the sake of innovation, when doing this work.

  8. Make the engineers/marketers from the Create study come back and show their nifty things: see which complement the key elements you've raised and add real consumer value.

  9. Map a TO-BE curve out of all this.

  10. Now ... iteratively go back and forth over the prior steps until you find a set of key elements that allow you to draw a TO-BE curve that matters. When you think you're there, use the Buyer Utility Map to see if it adds adequate value. If not, back to the Strategy Canvas.



All this should take a substantive amount of time and cause mental anguish. If everybody is giddy, happy, and/or relaxed you've missed something.

Finally, take your new curve and transform it into a business model that makes billions of dollars.

PS: About those flops... I attribute those more to managerial failure than to any issues with Blue Ocean Strategy. Using BOS honestly and accurately will churn out great businesses, but talented teams and managers are still needed to execute the models. For help with this, read the last third of the book.